Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

43 York Street
451 - Downtown St. Catharines L2R 6C2

$425,000
Residential Freehold beds: 4+2 baths: 5.0

Main Photo: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 1: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 2: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 3: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 4: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 5: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 6: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 7: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 8: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 9: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 10: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 11: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 12: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 13: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 14: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 15: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 16: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 17: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 18: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 19: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 20: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 21: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 22: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 23: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 24: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 25: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 26: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 27: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 28: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 29: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 30: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 31: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 32: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 33: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 34: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 35: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 36: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 37: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Photo 38: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
X13721904
Bedrooms:
4+2
Bathrooms:
5
LEGAL DUPLEX - VACANT UPPER UNIT - EXCELLENT INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY. Excellent opportunity to own a legal duplex in an established St. Catharines neighbourhood offering immediate rental income and strong future income potential. The main floor and lower level are occupied by great long-term tenants, providing reliable income from day one. The vacant second-floor unit gives the new owner the flexibility to select their own tenant and establish current market rent, creating an attractive opportunity to maximize overall income. For an owner-occupier, move into the vacant upper unit while benefiting from substantial rental income from the existing tenanted portion to help offset mortgage and carrying costs. The property features two self-contained units with separate private entrances and separate hydro meters. Additional features include an updated kitchen, coin laundry, private driveway, and front and rear decks. Conveniently located in the established Haig Street neighbourhood within walking distance of downtown St. Catharines, shopping, restaurants, entertainment and public transit. With legal duplex status, established tenants, a vacant upper unit, separate hydro meters, and strong income potential, this is a compelling opportunity for investors and owner-occupiers alike.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Duplex
Home Style:
2-Storey
Total Approx Floor Area:
1500-2000
Lot Depth:
87'2¾"
Lot Frontage:
41'
Direction Faces:
West
Bedrooms:
4+2
Bathrooms:
5.0
Water supply:
Municipal
Kitchens:
4
Kitchens in Basement:
2
Bedrooms Above Grade:
4
Bedrooms Below Grade:
2
Kitchens Above Grade:
2
Rooms Above Grade:
11
Rooms Below Grade:
4
Heating type:
Radiant
Heating Fuel:
Gas
Foundation:
Concrete
Roof:
Asphalt Shingle
Basement:
Full, Finished, Finished with Walk-Out
Fireplace/Stove:
No
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Parking Spaces:
3
Total Parking Spaces:
3.0
Family Room:
No
Possession Details:
ASAP Preferred
Pool:
None
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Not Subject to HST
Assessment Year:
2025
Taxes:
$3,250 / 2026
Assessment:
$- / 2025
Niagara
St. Catharines
451 - Downtown
Other
Brick, Other
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Sewer
Air Conditioning:
Window Unit(s)
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Date Listed:
Aug 28, 2026
Original Price:
Previous Price:
  • Photo 1: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 1 of 38
  • Photo 2: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 2 of 38
  • Photo 3: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 3 of 38
  • Photo 4: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 4 of 38
  • Photo 5: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 5 of 38
  • Photo 6: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 6 of 38
  • Photo 7: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 7 of 38
  • Photo 8: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 8 of 38
  • Photo 9: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 9 of 38
  • Photo 10: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 10 of 38
  • Photo 11: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 11 of 38
  • Photo 12: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 12 of 38
  • Photo 13: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 13 of 38
  • Photo 14: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 14 of 38
  • Photo 15: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 15 of 38
  • Photo 16: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 16 of 38
  • Photo 17: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 17 of 38
  • Photo 18: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 18 of 38
  • Photo 19: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 19 of 38
  • Photo 20: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 20 of 38
  • Photo 21: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 21 of 38
  • Photo 22: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 22 of 38
  • Photo 23: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 23 of 38
  • Photo 24: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 24 of 38
  • Photo 25: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 25 of 38
  • Photo 26: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 26 of 38
  • Photo 27: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 27 of 38
  • Photo 28: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 28 of 38
  • Photo 29: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 29 of 38
  • Photo 30: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 30 of 38
  • Photo 31: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 31 of 38
  • Photo 32: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 32 of 38
  • Photo 33: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 33 of 38
  • Photo 34: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 34 of 38
  • Photo 35: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 35 of 38
  • Photo 36: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 36 of 38
  • Photo 37: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 37 of 38
  • Photo 38: 43 York Street in St. Catharines: 451 - Downtown House for sale : MLS®# X13721904
    Photo 38 of 38
Listed by RE/MAX GARDEN CITY REALTY INC, BROKERAGE
Data was last updated August 29, 2026 at 11:15 PM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
13
Avg list price:
$489,900
Min list price:
$411,500
Max list price:
$799,900
Avg days on market:
51
Min days on market:
1
Max days on market:
324
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in 451 - Downtown. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website. The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.